Thursday, November 12, 2015

Wizards and Ogres - Part One

Know Thyself - Even If It's Painful

A tango enthusiast was enjoying the progress that he was making along his unique path through learning the dance. He studied every week. He practiced whenever he could. He went to milongas as often as was practical. 

Along the way he discovered a deep love for the tango and for the social world that surrounded it. He enjoyed discussing technique with his fellow dancers. He relished spending time in the embrace of sensitive followers as they moved together to beautiful music. He derived a great deal of satisfaction from learning new and challenging material.

One day, as the tanguero was working his way along his normal path, he arrived at a bridge. At the entrance to the bridge stood a bearded wizard and a huge, hideous ogre.

"Stop!" commanded the wizard. "We have been waiting for you!"

"What do you want?" asked the somewhat confused dancer.

"We have an important question to ask you."

"Okay, what do you want to know?"

"Do you understand your limitations?" the wizard asked cryptically.

"You mean, in tango?" the dancer asked.

"Yes, your tango limitations," the wizard clarified. "Do you understand what you'll need to work on in order to move forward from this point?"

The tango enthusiast thought for a moment. "Well, I want to learn volcadas and colgadas. I haven't had a chance to study those yet, because where I study, they only do them in the advanced class. And back sacadas. Hopefully, I'll be moving up to those classes soon."

Suddenly, the ogre lunged forward and gave the enthusiast a shove so forceful that it knocked him off his feet and sent him rolling along the ground.

"What was that for?" the enthusiast demanded as he climbed back to his feet and dusted himself off.

"Your answer was not satisfactory!" scolded the wizard.

"But I told you what I didn't know."

"Think harder!" commanded the wizard.

"Okay, um, well, I took a class in musicality once, but I didn't really understand what the teacher was trying to get us to do. So, I guess I'll have to work on that."

"Do you even understand what musicality means?"

"Not really."

The ogre roared and lunged toward the dancer again. The wizard intervened just in time to prevent another attack. 

"You are making him angry!" warned the wizard. "You need to tell us the TRUTH."

"I did tell you the truth," pleaded the enthusiast.

"You didn't tell us everything," the wizard said. "Think harder!"

The tanguero was clearly shaken and was having trouble concentrating.

"Maybe this will help," said the wizard as he pulled an iPad out of his robe. "We have some video of you dancing at a recent milonga. Observe! Tell us what you see!"

"Um, okay, well, I guess it's not too flashy, but I don't know that many steps yet."

"You don't have to worry about steps if you are improvising," the wizard stated. "Are you improvising here?"

"A little," admitted the tanguero. "I'm not really good at it yet."

"I see!" exclaimed the wizard. "What about quality of movement?"

"Uh, I look kind of stiff," answered the tango enthusiast.

"I see! What about technique?"

"Well, it looks fine on some steps, but it's definitely awkward in other places."

"Aha!" exclaimed the wizard. "Now we're getting somewhere!"

"Can I go now?" asked the clearly frightened tanguero.

"Just one more question," said the wizard. "Look at the follower. Does she look as though she is enjoying her dance with you?"

"Mmm, no, she looks kind of detached," admitted the dancer.

"She doesn't look happy?" asked the wizard.

"Not OVERLY happy ... I guess."

"And why is that?"

"Well, I remember her," recalled the dancer. "She wasn't very good."

The ogre howled and tossed the man to the ground more forcefully than the first time.

"Why wasn't this follower happy?" demanded the wizard.

"I ... I honestly don't know," admitted the now very sore tanguero.

"Yes, you don't know," repeated the wizard. "And that is the entire point of our discussion today. Here you are, parading through tango land like some privileged prince, thinking that everything is going well. You don't even understand the most basic elements and responsibilities of tango.

"You don't have good technique. You don't appreciate quality of movement. You don't understand music. You don't know how to improvise effectively. And worst of all, not only are you incapable of treating a follower to an enjoyable tanda, you don't even recognize when you have failed them!

"So, I'll ask you one more time: Why wasn't this follower happy?"

"I ... I'm not sure," admitted the dazed and desperate dancer as he picked himself up off of the ground for the second time. "I dance with other ladies, and everything is fine. It just wasn't very easy with this one."

"I strongly advise that you not anger my large friend here with talk like that!"

"Well, what am I supposed to do?" asked the tango enthusiast crossly. "Dance with every follower?"

"Yes!" cried the wizard. "When you ask a woman to dance with you, you take responsibility for her and for what happens to her on the dance floor. When she accepts your invitation, she puts her trust in you. Remember that she arrived with the same love for tango that YOU feel. Taking care of her - and reinforcing her love for the dance - that is all that you ever need to do. 

"You won't need colgadas to make a follower happy. You don't need to impress her with back sacadas or fancy combinations. You need to make sure that she feels better after her dances with you than she did when she accepted your invitation. And guess what? You FAILED! This is your one and only responsibility when you are at the milonga, and you failed."

"Okay! I get it," said the dancer. "I understand."

"What do you understand?"

"I understand my weaknesses."

"Well, that's good!" the wizard exclaimed cheerfully. "Then, you may proceed!"

"I can go?" asked the dancer as he warily eyed the ogre.

"Yes," replied the wizard. "And perhaps you should hurry before he becomes angry with you once again."

The dancer walked cautiously past the wizard and the ogre and began to cross the bridge. He had to make his way slowly, however, because dense fog was rising up off of the river below. Eventually, the fog thinned, and he was able to see the far side of the bridge. There, waiting for him, stood another wizard, and an even bigger ogre.

"Stop!" commanded the wizard. "We have been waiting for you!"






¡Buena suerte amigos, y muchas gracias!
Daniel

Copyright © 2015 The Exploring Tango Blog
All Rights Reserved


   



Thursday, September 10, 2015

Get To Class Early

Why You Can't Make Up For Lost Time

This is a simple idea. Get to class on time. Better yet, get there ahead of time so you can be warmed up and focused and ready when the instructor starts the lesson.

So, why would I bother writing about such a mundane topic? Because it's important. I'll explain why in a moment.


A Widespread Problem

Have you ever noticed people rushing into the classroom or dance studio at the last minute? Have you ever seen people changing their shoes, checking messages, chatting, or socializing while the instructor is already presenting material? This happens a lot.

Sometimes students arrive after the class has already started - five, ten, fifteen minutes late - maybe more. This isn't unusual either.


Time Pressure

Hey, I get it. I understand. We're all busy. Some of us attend classes after work. It's not always easy to depart from your place of business or finish a meeting with a client in time to arrive early for an extracurricular activity.

We may have families and children to manage amongst other responsibilities. It's not easy to leave your loved ones when they're dealing with some minor crisis. (Of course, if it's a major crisis, just stay home. You can catch up on the material another time. Devoting time to your family when they need you is a no-brainer.)

Traffic delays are common. Public transportation doesn't always run on time. The weather can slow everything down. That, plus your dog probably ate your homework.


The Importance Of Being Punctual 

Classes and workshops tend to follow a progressive flow. This won't be true in every instance or with every teacher, but in my experience, this is how most classes are run. 

What do I mean by following a progressive flow? Teachers present material, concepts, and/or exercises in the first few minutes of class with the expectation that they will build on this material as the class moves forward.

In order to build on the material that's introduced in the first few minutes, the students have to be ready to absorb and work on that material. People who are chatting or rushing to put on their shoes won't be fully focused. The guy who arrives seven minutes late because "traffic was horrible" won't see the exposition of the material, and he won't have a chance to practice the first exercise or two enough to make sense of it.

That's the problem. What can we do about it?


Making Up For Lost Time

Let's talk about those late arrivers for a moment. How can we manage them?

Option 1 - Explain and demonstrate the material all over again when the late people arrive. 

This means that the rest of the class has to wait for the late arrivers to catch up instead of moving on to more material that they (the on-time people) are now ready to handle. 

Even if we do explain and demonstrate the material for the later arrivers, they won't have enough time to assimilate it as the rest of the class moves forward. They'll feel frustrated. This problem multiplies itself if even more people arrive even later.

Option 2 - Let the on-time students practice for a song or two while you take time out to explain things to the late arrivers.

At best, this will be challenging. You're going to be explaining things to them in the corner of the room while the rest of the class is busy doing something else.

 You won't be able to give the on-time students as much focus as they deserve, because the late arrivers now demand your focus. And the late arrivers still won't have enough time to practice the material before moving on.

Option 3 - Just move forward. Focus your energy and attention on the people who were committed to arriving on time. If the late arrivers can't catch up, they can repeat the class or schedule a private lesson in order to catch up. 

Of course, they're going to be annoyed. They paid the same price for the class as the on-time students, and they expect to walk away with an understanding of the material. They don't see any reason why you can't take time out to catch them up on the material. (At least, they didn't until they read Options 1 and 2 above.) 

They don't want to pay extra money for an hour of lessons just so you can show them something that you explained five minutes ago. And you know what? They have a point. If you overlook the needs of your latecomers more than a few times, and they'll leave your school and look for instruction elsewhere.

The important idea is that it's not possible to make up for lost time in a way that will work effectively for everyone. Students need to be present and ready from the beginning of the class if they want to get the most out of the material. If someone arrives even a little bit late, it's not possible to straighten that out without inconveniencing someone. It's that simple.


Being There

I understand this problem from all sides. I have a habit of running late, and I was never terribly punctual about getting to my tango classes. At the time, I didn't realize the kind of problems that this could cause. So, I'd like to apologize to my teachers for being a pain in the ass.

My perspective changed when started teaching. I realized quickly how challenging it is to catch the late people up on the material when the early people are ready to move forward. It's not a fun situation for anyone.

That said, in the four years that I taught tango classes, I was late only one time - and by "late" I mean that I walked into the studio at the time that the class was due to start. I needed to take a couple of extra minutes in order to change my shoes and use the restroom before starting the class. Luckily, this happened only once. 

I made it a point to arrive at my classes early. I made it a point to be there well in advance of the arrival of my students, to be focused and ready to go when they were. I factored in likely delays due to traffic and weather, so I was rarely surprised by a delay that I couldn't manage. It's possible to be on time or ahead of time EVERY time if you commit yourself to it.

It is worth the effort? Yes, and not just because it makes things easier for your teacher. It will make things easier for you. We learn better when we don't feel stressed or hurried. 

If you pay for a one hour class or a two-hour workshop, why not get the most out of that time? Why put yourself through the stress of trying to catch up when you can simply be there from the beginning, see all of the demonstrations, and participate in all of the exercises?

No matter who your teacher is, make sure that you arrive on time for class. You'll get so much more out of the experience.

And remember what they say: "Five minutes early, is five minutes late."



¡Buena suerte amigos, y muchas gracias!
Daniel

Copyright © 2015 The Exploring Tango Blog
All Rights Reserved




   

Sunday, August 23, 2015

My Biggest Failure

To Come So Far And Be So Close

Students progress at different rates. Some people pick up new movements with ease, while others have to work harder and put in more time to reach the same level of competence and fluidity. 

That said, the vast majority of students make steady progress over time when they show up and put in the effort. But occasionally we encounter a student who struggles to execute the simplest movements or grasp the most fundamental concepts.

These students are highly motivated. They want to learn. They want to make progress. They show up week after week and try as hard as they can. Unfortunately, sometimes they end up trying too hard. Their work ethic actually creates roadblocks to their progress.

One lady stands out in my memory. She was so nice, and she tried so hard. But she struggled simply because she wouldn't let herself relax and respond to the lead. She seemed to be convinced that she had to execute the steps and sequences actively. She wouldn't just relax and let the leader take her on a ride. 

I encouraged her constantly. I spent a lot of time with her in the class; I could see the other leaders becoming frustrated with her, and I didn't want her to feel their judgment. She felt badly enough already. I could see the disappointment and frustration in her face.

"Forget the step," I would tell her. 

"Just relax and move with me." 

"Go where the lead takes you." 

"Follow my shoulders."

"You have plenty of time. Just relax."

"Abandon the plan and just dance."

Eventually, after months of encouragement, my struggling student finally made a breakthrough. She finally relaxed and let herself respond to the lead. It was an amazing experience for both of us.

"You see?" I ask. "It's effortless."

"It is!" she replied enthusiastically.

You should have seen the look on her face. She was glowing. She did so well that evening that I asked her to dance with me for the closing demo of the class. Her transformation was amazing.

She came back the following week, and we shared several smooth, flowing dances together. She danced as though she was floating on a cloud. I was so happy for her.

The school closed for a couple of weeks during the holidays, and that closing was followed by a period of bad weather.I didn't see my student for while. When she returned a month or so later, she had reverted to her old habits. She struggled as though the breakthrough had never happened. 

I was confident that I could work with her and encourage her to get back on track. Unfortunately, for whatever reason, she returned only once more. I never saw her again after that.

I don't know what happened. Perhaps she grew weary of the frustration. Maybe someone criticized her. Maybe she simply decided that tango wasn't for her, that it was too challenging.

It broke my heart when I realized that she wasn't coming back. I wish that I could have inspired her to stick around for a little bit longer. She had her breakthrough, and it would have happened again with a bit more time and encouragement. 

But it wasn't to be. All of my encouragement and reassurance wasn't enough to inspire her to continue. It was my biggest failure as a teacher.

I always tried to understand each student's individual needs and provide them with personalized instruction. The students who stuck with me always made progress. I'm so proud to watch those students today. They dance beautifully.

But no one's breakthrough meant more to me than this one. This lady struggled so hard for so long. To watch her finally dance and flow in the moment. That was very, very special. I hope that she remembers those dances as fondly as I do.

Hers was a difficult journey. I sympathize if she just didn't want to work that hard anymore. But I hope that she'll give the tango another chance one day. Because I know that she can do it. 




¡Buena suerte amigos, y muchas gracias!
Daniel

Copyright © 2015 The Exploring Tango Blog
All Rights Reserved


   

Wednesday, August 12, 2015

Sloppy Tango 2 - The Waste of Haste

How Rushing Can Destroy Your Tango

"Take time for all things: great haste makes great waste." - Benjamin Franklin

Benjamin Franklin never saw a milonga, and that's too bad because he would have loved tango. He would have loved the boundless expressive and emotive qualities of the dance. He would have loved the geometry of the steps. He would have loved the passionate, brooding music. And, he so would have enjoyed sharing long, sultry nights in the embrace of lithe and capable women in Paris and his native Philadelphia.

Ah, Ben! What you missed, old friend!


Haste Makes Waste

As Franklin observed, bad things happen when we rush. Very bad things happen to our tango technique when we rush our movements. I'll explain why in a moment, but first a word of caution.

Rushing is an equal opportunity problem. I have seen experienced, skilled dancers at milongas make an absolute mockery of tango technique by rushing too quickly through steps. I'm sure that these people thought that their dancing was impressive, and in a way, it was: impressively hideous and brutally uncomfortable to watch.


The Four Stages Of A Movement

Every elemental movement (step, gancho, boleo, barrida, etc.) has four components.

1. Intention/Preparation - Preparing mentally and physically to move.

2. Initiation - The start of the movement.

3. Travel - The body of the movement where most of the distance is covered (if applicable).

4. Resolution - The conclusion of the movement where the dancers return to a neutral and (typically) balanced position.

If we take a forward step, we prepare to move, we initiate the movement, we move through space, and then we reach a point where we are balanced and our feet are collected.


Breakdown Of The Problem

Consider the Forward Ocho. You learned in your second or third Beginners' class and probably haven't thought much about since. The simplicity of the ocho sequence coupled with its dependence on pivots makes it susceptible to distortion by rushing.

The Forward Ocho sequence is a repeating pattern that consists of a forward step followed by a pivot. 

Note: The forward step of the ocho is very simple. It doesn't contain any sweeping, curling, or pivoting components or any boleo or planeo like adornments. It's just a simple forward cross step. (It's called a "Cross" step, because you're stepping across the line of your forward intention, but don't worry about that if you're unfamiliar with the term.)

As described above this simple forward step has four parts: intention, initiation, travel, and resolution.

What happens when we rush through an ocho? To be more precise, what happens if the leader begins to lead the pivot before the follower completes these four stages of her forward step?

It's simple. The follower is forced for pivot before her body is balanced on her axis. That result is that she is trying to pivot while she is leaning to the side. This is a difficult and uncomfortable movement to execute.


The Fix

The fix is simple. Don't lead the follower to pivot until she completes her forward step and arrives on her axis.

But, the difference is HUGE: a poised, controlled, flowing ocho versus a stumbling, tilting, uncomfortable off-balance mess.


Other Steps That Can Be Ruined by Rushing

The Molinete - The follower needs to have time to arrive on axis and bring her feet together cleanly before making her next movement, be it a pivot or a step.

Ganchos - Ganchos require proper timing and alignment. Either or both can be corrupted by rushing.

Boleos - Boleos are interrupted ochos, so the same off-axis problem applies. Also, the musical timing of the snap of the boleo movement will be off if either partner tries to rush the movement.

Paradas - The follower can trip if the parada is placed too early.

There are others, but you get the idea. 


Slow Down and Enjoy the Dance

Finish each movement completely and cleanly before moving on. When in doubt take more time rather than less. If you note stumbling in your dancing, check for situations where technique is being rushed.

Keep your technique clean. You'll be less sore and less tired at the end of the evening, your dancing will look better, and you'll have a lot more fun.

Until next time, keep what's important in mind.



¡Buena suerte amigos, y muchas gracias!
Daniel

Copyright © 2015 The Exploring Tango Blog
All Rights Reserved


   

Sunday, May 31, 2015

Sloppy Tango 1 - Stumbling

Lacking Stability

I see the same mistakes year after year at milongas and practicas. It's difficult to watch, because in many cases these are simple problems that could have been corrected with awareness and a small amount of effort. 

I realize that most tangueros are social dancers who dance for fun. That's wonderful! I want them to HAVE fun. I want them to ENJOY their time on the dance floor regardless of their level of experience. I want them to walk out of the building at the end of the evening feeling confident and energized. 

When are you more likely to feel confident and energized? When you're dancing well and your technique is flowing smoothly? Or after an evening of struggle, discomfort, and disappointment? 


Opportunities For Avoidance

There are three ways to deal with a challenge: Quit, Avoid, or Improve. 

Some people quit. They decide that tango isn't worth the effort anymore, so they more on to other activities. It's sad when people give up on something that once promised so much joy and fulfillment.

A more common way to deal with challenges is to avoid acknowledging them or to avoids taking responsibility for their resolution. We might be tempted to blame others for out difficulties. 

"There are no good dancers around here. I have to go to Milonga X to find good people to dance with."

"I'm not coming back to this milonga. The people are rude, and the music is horrible."

"I stopped taking their classes. The material wasn't advanced enough for me."

 I hear comments like this quite frequently, and I'll bet that you have, too. 

Avoiders are prone to change teachers frequently, jump prematurely to higher level classes, or abandon a neighborhood milonga. None of these choices are inherently bad. But until the person takes responsibility for addressing their own developmental needs, improvement will come slowly and be largely coincidental.

Here's a hint. The quality of your dancing begins with YOU. You'll never outrun your weaknesses. Never. They'll follow you to your last day on Earth unless you face them and take corrective action. Avoidance won't get you to where you want to do.



It Begins With Awareness


Awareness is the first step toward improvement. Maybe by writing about the widespread issues that I'm seeing, I can inspire some folks to strive to change.


Stumbling Blocks

Awareness Exercise Número Uno - This is the single most common technical problem that I see at milongas. I see lots of followers stumbling from step to step instead of moving gracefully with confidence and clarity. Foot placement is hesitant and unsure, as if the follower isn't clear as to when and where to take the step. Movements are tentative and lack smoothness and expression. 

Sadly, this is a widespread problem. I see it everywhere I go. But why is this happening? What is the root cause, and how can it be addressed effectively?

I'm certain that every lady at the milonga walked into the salon smoothly and confidently. And I'm certain that they'll walk beautifully when they leave at the end of the evening. Why is it that they can't walk smoothly and confidently when they're dancing in the embrace of a gentleman?

To be fair, the gentleman might be contributing to the problem. Leaders knock followers off balance with some frequency. The leader's embrace might be interfering with her posture at a critical moment. Or the man's lower body might be too far forward, causing the follower to trip over his feet. The timing of his steps might be inconsistent with the timing of his lead.

But we can't always blame the leader, because it's not always his fault. Sometimes the followers fail to take care of their own stability. They rely too heavily on the embrace for support.



A Simple Test

Ladies, sometime when you have a chance to practice with a leader who's willing to work with you patiently, ask him to lead a short sequence of tango steps in three different levels of embrace. 

First, run through the sequence in the full embrace. 

Now, try the sequence again, but this time let go of each other on the closed side of the embrace. This means that he is not holding you with his right arm, and you are not holding him with your left arm or hand.

Are you still able to execute the steps? Is it more difficult to dance without the full support of the embrace? Do you find that your balance is challenged at one or more points within the sequence?

For the third try, separate a bit further. Now, your only contact point will be your right hand in the leader's left. Don't worry - you won't have to dance like this in a milonga - this is only an exercise. But in order to do the exercise successfully, you'll need to manage your own balance. Your legs will need to support you completely.

Can you do it?

Try the whole three-stage exercise again with a different step sequence. Start in the full embrace. Try it again without connection in the closed-side arms. Then, try it a third time with contact only in the open-side hands.

Ideally, a follower should be able to execute most tango sequences without relying on the leader's frame for balance. There are exceptions, of course, which cannot be done without support from the partner (volcadas, colgadas, lifts). But you should be able to do most steps smoothly and confidently while supported by your own balance.

Please remember that this is only an exercise. Dancing like this in a milonga is not recommended. The embrace is important, and we should use it to its fullest benefit while we're dancing.

But followers shouldn't depend on the embrace for stability. Stability begins with our own legs and hips even when we are dancing very close to our partner. In order to step confidently in response to the lead, the follower needs to feel stable within the structure of her own body.




¡Buena suerte amigos, y muchas gracias!
Daniel

Copyright © 2015 The Exploring Tango Blog
All Rights Reserved


   


   

Sunday, April 19, 2015

Talent, Effort and Dedication

How Far Will They Take You?

Occasionally, someone compliments me by remarking that I am a talented photographer. I accept comments like this graciously and enthusiastically - it's always nice when someone appreciates my work. But I realize that talent isn't what made me a photographer.  

For most of my life, I was a casual snap-shooter. I took bad photographs for decades. When I look back over my albums from those years, I don't see much evidence of talent shining through. 

After seeing some awe-inspiring photo exhibits, I came to realize that cameras could do a lot more than I thought. There was more to photography than the faded, poorly composed rubbish that I was picking up regularly at my neighborhood drugstore.

Eventually, I dedicated myself to becoming a serious photographer. I felt a burning desire to make photos like the ones that had impressed me in those shows. I dedicated time to learning everything that I could about cameras and the photographic process. But even as I was learning and developing skills, I still made lots of bad photos.

Talent didn't make me a photographer. Work and honest self-evaluation were the most critical factors in my development. I took lots of photos, rated my progress, devised new approaches, and went out and shot some more. Over and over and over again. Over time, I learned a lot and improved my skills in the process.


The Diamond Under The Mountain

I have met people with a real talent for photography, people who have impressed me with a natural gift for composition or a sense for finding fascinating subjects. Some of these folks have impressive portfolios. Some have modest portfolios that show untapped promise. And some are casual snap-shooters who upload mostly unimpressive photos to social media on occasion. 

All of these people have talent, but only some of them have achieved impressive results. The difference is in the effort and determination that they have committed toward achieving those results.

Talent is potential. Exceptional talent will let someone achieve more in the same amount of time or with the same amount of effort. But without effort, that talent will remain unfulfilled. Talent is a diamond buried under a mountain. You'll have to dig deep before you can access its full value.


Limitations

A lack of talent does enforce some limitations. Most people will never compete in a professional sporting event or sing on stage at a famous opera house. The people who make it to that level all have extraordinary talent. But talent didn't put them on the stage or the playing field. Top performers typically dedicate countless hours toward developing and maximizing their talent. 

A person with average talent can achieve impressive results by committing themselves to hard work and a plan for making the best of the abilities that they have. Maybe they won't discover a diamond under their personal mountain, but they'll find other beautiful and valuable assets. In many cases, their lives will be more fulfilling for having put in the effort.


A Weakness Exposed

I have been blessed with some degree of talent, and I am thankful for all that those talents have enabled me to achieve. But there are plenty of areas in my life where I lack talent to an embarrassingly painful degreed.

A lack of scholastic talent emerged as a critical weakness when I went to college (university, for international readers). It wasn't just that I struggled to get good grades. I plunged into a downward spiral that led to some of the most difficult and disappointing years of my life.  

I read very slowly. It takes me three to six weeks to read an average-sized novel. I know people who can finish the same book in an evening or two. 

That might not sound like a big problem, but it became a serious disadvantage when I started studying at the university level. I struggled to complete assignments, I fell desperately behind semester after semester, and my grades were horrible. Not just bad - horrible! I was frustrated, exhausted, depressed, ashamed, and I felt utterly hopeless. I feared that I would never earn a degree, and I had no idea what I could do to reverse the damage.

With each new semester, I resolved to do better, to study harder, but I still struggled. In fact, things got worse. Much worse.

Finally, after it seemed that all hope of ever getting through college was lost, I had a breakthrough. I resolved to do whatever it took to earn good grades and complete my degree. 

I scheduled as many hours of study time as I could find available each week, and I wouldn't let these periods be skipped or interrupted. I found the quietest places on campus and spent hours there every day (effectively hiding) in order to avoid distraction. In my notebooks, I paraphrased every paragraph that I read as I was reading it. I imagined myself standing before a classroom full of students, explaining the material. I needed to understand every concept and every detail in order to avoid looking like a fool.

I didn't gain any scholastic talent overnight. The Learning Fairy didn't cast a magic spell on me. My reading pace was still ponderously slow. 

But by refining my approach to studying in a way that compensated for my weaknesses, I went from being an academic embarrassment to getting A's in three-fourths of my classes. I completed my degree, and I went on to have a long, successful career in a field where continuous learning is demanded.

Those speedy readers obviously have more talent than I do in this area. I doubt that I could ever survive in law school or medical school - which is just fine, because they would never accept me anyway. But I was able to find a way to overcome my academic weaknesses. The dedication and effort required were significant, but it did prove to be possible. 

Desire and commitment and hard work can move anyone forward toward any dream. If you have talent, you'll be able to go a little farther, but you're still going to have to work hard to get there. If you don't have a lot of talent, you can still do many of the things that you dream of doing. 

Never let a perceived lack of talent discourage you. Maybe you don't lack talent at all; you might need to try something different in order to develop your unique potential. Keep working at it. Keep trying new approaches. Good things are waiting for you. There are diamonds hiding under the mountain, but it will take work to find them.


¡Buena suerte amigos, y muchas gracias!
Daniel

Copyright © 2015 The Exploring Tango Blog
All Rights Reserved


   


   

Saturday, April 11, 2015

Why Feedback In Class Is A Big Deal

A Perspective On Teaching Styles

Some years ago, I signed up for a bunch of tango classes at a respected school in my area. They had a program where you could pay one price and take as many classes as you'd like. It seemed like a good deal. I was eager to work hard and learn as much as I could.

I knew some of the teachers from previous classes, but some were unfamiliar to me. It turns out that one of them was very well known in the tango world. I didn't realize this when I signed up. I had been dancing for two or three years, but there was still a lot that I didn't know about the scene. 

This particular teacher - we'll call her Miss Big Deal - attracted a lot of students to her classes. Space in the room was tight but not unmanageable.

The classes followed the standard "one sequence per week" format, where the students spend an hour learning a single, moderately intricate series of movements that are meant to be performed together. The teacher explains the sequence in chunks starting at the beginning. The unspoken objective is to get through the entire sequence by the end of the class and hopefully pick up some technical tips along the way.

This isn't my favorite format for learning - for a whole host of reason that I'll save for another blog post - but it's very common. In my experience, most classes by most teachers follow this format. As a student, you deal with it and try to learn and remember as much as you can.


A Non-Learning Experience

After years of classes, I find it fairly easy to learn a new step sequence. The teacher instructs the class to do A-B-C, so I do A-B-C. They ask us to add D-E-F, so I do. Unless one of the steps in the sequence presents a technical challenge, or unless it goes poorly with multiple partners, I tend not to ask many questions. I figure that the teacher needs to spend their time with the students who are struggling.

That said, I do appreciate when a teacher passes on an occasional tip or insight. Technique can always be improved. Ideally, the teacher will notice something that I'm doing incorrectly or ineffectively and mention or demonstrate how I might go about improving it. Even in a fairly large class, it's possible to pass on a bit of feedback to each student.

Miss Big Deal didn't offer much advice. She made no attempt to wander through the class offering suggestions to individual students.

Miss Big did spend time with couples who asked her for help directly - typically those who were having a hard time learning the sequence. I applauded her for spending time with them, but she didn't share any information from those discussions. There was no follow up announcement to clarify for the entire class a point that one or two students had raised.

On two occasions, I was able to get Miss Deal's attention. I asked her to help me understand why something wasn't working. She would motion for us to execute the sequence, watch silently for a few seconds, and then walk away without making a comment. The expression on her face was one of utter disinterest.


Seeking Answers

I probably shouldn't have wasted my time in that class, but since it was part of a package deal, I kept at it for five months. During that time I received no feedback from this teacher, none whatsoever. No feedback was offered spontaneously. No feedback was given when I asked for it. 

I might have tried to ask a few more times, but there was a constant frenzy for her attention in class, particularly from a handful of people who seemed to require explanations for everything. I wondered how they managed to arrive at the school on time without her explicit direction.

Undeterred, I went to the front desk one day and asked whether I could schedule a private lesson with Miss Biggie. They informed me that Miss Deal's private lessons were booked solid for months in advance and that cancellations were rare. I couldn't even BUY feedback from this highly-regarded expert.


For The Record

The class was effectively a complete waste of my time. I forgot the sequences nearly as quickly as I learned them. There wasn't much discussion of technique as we memorized those soon to be forgotten steps. Occasionally, she would mention a mistake to avoid. Corrective feedback was of course, non-existent. I didn't even see her offering words of encouragement.

In all fairness to Miss Big Deal, however, I would like to mention a more positive experience. I took a weekend seminar with her a few months later. The information presented was well organized and helped me increase my understanding of tango significantly. I didn't receive any feedback, of course, but it was still a valuable educational experience. 


The Importance Of Giving Feedback

I give feedback to every one of my students in every single class.

Why? Because I care about their progress. Because I want them to become better dancers quickly and directly, not haphazardly. Because I want them to get some value for the time and money and effort that they have invested into their time with me.

I let each student know, in a gentle and supportive way, where their weaknesses are and where they'll need to focus their efforts in order to improve.

I try to catch students in the act of making a mistake, even if I have to ask them to repeat a movement a few times. I want them to understand the problem as it occurs in real time. 

I'll demonstrate the proper technique side by side with the way that they were doing it. I want the difference to be absolutely clear in their minds so they know WHAT they'll need to practice and WHY it's important.

Feedback is absolutely critical to the learning process. Why do people take classes for years and not make much progress? It's probably due to a lack of feedback. If you don't know what you're doing wrong, you're not going to fix it.

If you want to be happily mediocre for the rest of your life, don't bother to look at the details. Just keep doing what you've always done. But if you really want to improve, the quickest and most effective way is to address your weaknesses.

Feedback is a big deal. I'm not a big deal. I don't have private lessons booked solid for months in advance. But I know that I have helped every student who has walked into one of my classes with even a modest desire to improve to do so. I coached them, I encouraged them, and I helped them to become a better dancer than they were when they walked in the door that day. That might not be a big deal, but it's good enough for me.



¡Buena suerte amigos, y muchas gracias!
Daniel

Copyright © 2015 The Exploring Tango Blog
All Rights Reserved